They Didn't Free Us. They Got Paid.

How a slave rebellion in Jamaica became one of the biggest paydays in British history

At Christmas 1831, the enslaved people of western Jamaica stopped working. Led by Samuel Sharpe, a Baptist deacon who was himself enslaved, as many as 60,000 people refused to work until they were paid. When the planters refused, the strike became an uprising. Plantations burned.

The British crushed it. Between 310 and 340 people were executed through the courts, many of them for property crimes like stealing livestock. Sharpe was hanged in May 1832. According to a missionary who visited him in his cell, he said he would rather die on the gallows than live in slavery.

But the message reached London. Parliament held two inquiries, and the conclusion was hard to escape: slavery could no longer be held down. Less than two years later, Britain abolished it.

That's the first thing to get straight. Freedom was not a gift. It was taken.

Emancipation, as Britain celebrated it. Image: Internet Archive Book Images, via Wikimedia Commons (no known copyright restrictions).

Explainer · scroll

Follow the £20 Million

From a Jamaican uprising to a debt cleared in 2015. Every step has a receipt.

Prices = what it would buy. Share of economy = how big it was relative to Britain then (UCL's measure).

1833 moneyToday: pricesToday: share of economy

1. 1/8 · Christmas 1831

   Jamaica stops working

   Led by Sam Sharpe, up to 60,000 enslaved people in western Jamaica refuse to work until they are paid. The strike becomes an uprising. Britain crushes it: between 310 and 340 people are executed.

   Receipt · Sam Sharpe (opens in a new tab)

2. 2/8 · 1833

   The loan becomes a gift

   The inquiry says a £15m loan is fair. It becomes a £15m gift. Then a £20m gift, about 40% of everything the government spent in a year.

   “Instead of a loan of 15,000,000l., to obtain a gift of twenty!”

   Receipt · Hansard, 24 Jul 1833 (opens in a new tab)

3. 3/8 · 1834–1838

   Freedom on layaway

   “Freed” people become apprentices, owing up to 45 unpaid hours a week to the same masters. The owners get the cash and the labour. Pressure ends it early, on 1 August 1838.

   Receipt · Hansard, 22 Jul 1833 (opens in a new tab)

4. 4/8 · 3 August 1835

   One bid left on the table

   Rothschild, Montefiore, Ricardo and Sir John Rae Reid raise £15m. Another £5m is issued as government stock. Reid’s firm held 1,229 enslaved people and took £17,894 in compensation. He called the loan “an excellent bargain.”

   Receipt · Rothschild Archive (opens in a new tab)

5. 5/8 · Where it went

   Over half stayed in Britain

   Most of the money went to absentee owners and lenders who never set foot on a plantation. The biggest single payout: John Gladstone, £106,769 for 2,508 people.

   Receipt · UCL (opens in a new tab)

6. 6/8 · The bankers' cut

   Bought at £86, worth £100

   The syndicate bought government stock at about £86 for every £100 of value and sold it on. Joseph Hume told Parliament the terms cost the public an extra £2.6m. The Chancellor disputed his maths.

   Receipt · Hansard, 4 Sep 1835 (opens in a new tab)

7. 7/8 · February 2015

   Paid off, 180 years later

   The debt was rolled over again and again. It was finally redeemed in 2015, paying out to 11,098 accounts. Taxpayers covered the interest the whole time.

   Receipt · Kris Manjapra (opens in a new tab)

8. 8/8 · The total

   Freed people received: £0.

   No land. No money. Four more years of unpaid work.

   Receipt · UCL (opens in a new tab)

The owners set the price

Abolition came with a bill, and the slave owners wrote it.

In 1833, the government's own inquiries concluded that a loan of £15 million would be fair relief for the planters. They would borrow it and pay it back. The West India lobby pushed, and the loan became a gift of £15 million. Then they pushed again, and it became a gift of £20 million.

One MP was furious and said so in Parliament: "Instead of a loan of 15,000,000l., to obtain a gift of twenty!"

£20 million was about 40% of everything the British government spent in a year. In today's money, that's about £2 billion if you only adjust for prices. But historians measure it by its share of the economy, and by that measure it's about £16.5 billion. The people who had been enslaved received nothing.

Freedom on layaway

They didn't even get full freedom. Under the Act, "freed" people became "apprentices." Field workers were bound for six more years and household workers for four. They owed up to 45 hours of unpaid labour a week to the same masters.

So the owners got the cash and the labour. The same MP called apprenticeship slavery under another name. It took more pressure and more resistance to end it early, on August 1, 1838.

Who lent the money

The government didn't have £20 million lying around. It covered £5 million by issuing government stock and borrowed the other £15 million from the City of London.

On August 3, 1835, only one bid was left on the table. It came from four men: Nathan Mayer Rothschild, Moses Montefiore, Mr Ricardo and Sir John Rae Reid.

Nathan Rothschild was the founder of the London branch of the Rothschild banking family, the same family you've heard about. He made his first money in Manchester trading cloth woven from slave-grown cotton, then became the biggest lender to governments in Europe. He moved in abolitionist circles and did business with Thomas Fowell Buxton, the man who led abolition through Parliament. But records uncovered in 2009 show he had also accepted enslaved people as collateral on a loan to a slave owner. When that borrower went bust, Rothschild used the compensation fund to recover his money.

Moses Montefiore was his brother-in-law and partner.

Sir John Rae Reid was a Member of Parliament, and his firm owned six plantations and 1,229 enslaved people in the Virgin Islands. He collected £17,894 in compensation. When another MP challenged the loan's terms in Parliament, Reid stood up and called it an excellent bargain for the public. He went on to become Governor of the Bank of England.

So one of the men who lent the money also collected it and defended the deal.

Follow the money

Here's how the money moved, step by step.

1. The owners swapped a dying asset for cash. By the 1830s, sugar estates were struggling and deep in debt. After the rebellion, the people they "owned" were a risk, not just an asset. Picture a landlord whose building is falling apart and whose tenants are about to revolt. Then the government buys him out, pays cash, and lets him collect rent for four more years. That's what compensation plus apprenticeship was.

2. The lenders got bailed out. Many plantations were mortgaged to merchants in Britain, and enslaved people were the collateral. Once slavery ended, those loans looked worthless. Compensation paid them off with public money. Over half of the £20 million went to people living in Britain, mostly absentee owners and lenders who had never set foot on a plantation.

3. The biggest winners got richer. The largest single payout went to John Gladstone, father of a future prime minister: £106,769 for 2,508 people on nine plantations, worth around £80 million today by the same share-of-the-economy measure. That money didn't sit still. Compensation flowed into railways, banks and property, assets that kept making money for generations.

4. The bankers took their cut. The syndicate bought government stock in bulk, at about £86 for every £100 of value, and sold it on to investors. That gap is how loan contractors make money. One MP, Joseph Hume, argued the deal cost the public an extra £2.6 million. The Chancellor disputed his maths. Exactly how much the syndicate made has never been fully documented.

5. The bondholders were paid for 180 years. This is the part most people miss. A government bond is money that works for you. Whoever holds it collects interest every year without lifting a finger, and the taxpayer pays it. The debt was rolled over and repackaged again and again. It wasn't finally cleared until February 2015, when the government paid out to 11,098 accounts.

That includes the years when the children and grandchildren of the enslaved, living in Britain, paid taxes too.

The principle

Abolition took human beings, a risky asset, and turned them into government debt, a safe one. The wealthy owned the debt, and everyone else paid it.

The owners got paid. The lenders got paid. The bondholders got paid for 180 years. The people who rose up and won their freedom got nothing: no land, no money, and four more years of unpaid work.

Today, Jamaica is asking the Privy Council in London whether any of it was ever lawful.

They didn't free us. They got paid.

---